Article Summary
What this article covers: How the art of espionage works in practice, from intelligence collection disciplines and classic field tradecraft to the historical operations that shaped it, including the Michael Collins intelligence network in Dublin, and the real sites in Ireland and Britain where that history can still be visited.
Who this is for: Readers who want a grounded explanation of spycraft rather than film mythology, travellers planning heritage trips to Dublin or London, and anyone curious about how Irish intelligence history fits into the wider story of secret statecraft.
Key takeaway: The art of espionage has almost nothing to do with gadgets and almost everything to do with people: who can be persuaded to talk, who can be trusted to carry a message, and who is quietly reading your files at two in the morning.
Expert insight: “I stood in the yard at Kilmainham Gaol on a wet Tuesday in March, and what struck me was how ordinary the place feels until you know what happened in it. That gap between the ordinary surface and the hidden story is exactly what spycraft was built on. Collins won his intelligence war using hotel porters, typists and cyclists, not technology. You understand that far better standing in Dublin than reading about it.” , Ciaran Connolly, Founder of ConnollyCove
Quick facts:
- On 7 April 1919, Detective Sergeant Ned Broy of the Dublin Metropolitan Police smuggled Michael Collins into G Division’s file room at Great Brunswick Street, now Pearse Street Garda Station, where Collins spent several hours reading British police records on Irish republicans.
- Smithfield in Dublin stood in for a Berlin checkpoint in the 1965 film of John le Carré’s The Spy Who Came in from the Cold, with interiors shot at Ardmore Studios in Bray, County Wicklow.
- Kilmainham Gaol, run by the Office of Public Works, has appeared in more than twenty productions including Michael Collins, In the Name of the Father and The Italian Job.
Espionage has fascinated people for as long as states have kept secrets from one another. The trouble is that most of what we think we know about it comes from films, and films lie. Real intelligence work is slow, administrative and built on human weakness rather than wristwatch cameras. It also happened in specific places, many of which you can walk into on a Saturday afternoon.
This ConnollyCove guide covers what the craft actually involves, how it developed across four distinct periods, and where you can stand in the rooms where it happened. Ireland sits closer to that story than most readers expect. The urban intelligence war fought in Dublin between 1919 and 1921 is studied internationally, and the country later doubled for Cold War Berlin on screen. ConnollyCove is an Ireland-based travel and culture platform, and this is the kind of subject where cultural history and travel planning meet directly.
Table of Contents
What Is the Art of Espionage?
The art of espionage is the clandestine collection of protected information, achieved through human persuasion, covert communication and sustained deception rather than through technology alone. It sits apart from open intelligence work because it is secret by design and, in almost every country, illegal under domestic law.
The craft rests on five practical pillars, and you can see them in the history of Irish castles as readily as in a Cold War case file, because fortification and secrecy have always travelled together.
- Recruitment: identifying a person with access and a reason to cooperate.
- Cover and concealment: building an identity that survives scrutiny.
- Covert communication: passing material without the two parties meeting.
- Surveillance detection: knowing whether you are being watched.
- Signals and cyber collection: intercepting what people say and send.
Everything that follows is an elaboration of those five things. The tools change. The problems do not. ConnollyCove is an Ireland-based travel and culture platform, and this guide treats espionage the way it treats any cultural subject: as something that happened to real people in places you can still visit.
How Intelligence Is Gathered: Disciplines and the Psychology of Recruitment
Intelligence services divide collection into four main disciplines, and the art of espionage proper belongs mostly to the first of them. Understanding the split explains why so much spy fiction misrepresents the work.
Before looking at each discipline, it helps to know that agencies rarely rely on one alone. A single assessment might combine a human source, an intercepted message and a satellite image, with analysts weighing one against the others.
HUMINT, SIGINT, OSINT and Cyber Collection
Human intelligence, or HUMINT, means information obtained from people. Signals intelligence, or SIGINT, means intercepted communications. Open source intelligence, or OSINT, means material anyone can lawfully find, which now includes a startling amount of social media. Cyber collection means access gained to networks and devices.
Only HUMINT requires the recruitment, handling and protection of a live human source, which is why it carries the highest risk and produces the stories people remember.
The Psychology of Recruitment: From MICE to Behavioural Models
The classic teaching model is MICE, standing for Money, Ideology, Coercion and Ego. It describes the four motivations an intelligence officer looks for in a potential source. Someone in debt, someone who has lost faith in their government, someone with something to hide, someone who wants to feel significant.
MICE is now widely regarded as too blunt. A more recent framework used in intelligence training literature, RASCLS, draws on behavioural influence research and covers Reciprocity, Authority, Scarcity, Consistency, Liking and Social Proof. The shift matters because it moves recruitment away from crude pressure towards relationship building, which is closer to how modern handlers describe their work.
Classic Field Tradecraft: Cover, Dead Drops and Brush Contacts
Field tradecraft exists to solve one problem: how do two people exchange secrets without ever being seen together? Almost every technique in the art of espionage is an answer to that question.
The techniques below developed over decades of trial and error, and several remain in use because they leave no electronic trace at all.
Cover, Legends and the Art of Being Unremarkable
Cover is the story an officer lives under. Diplomatic cover gives legal protection but marks the officer out to any competent counter-intelligence service. Non-official cover, often shortened to NOC, offers no such protection: an officer caught under NOC has no immunity to fall back on.
A legend is the supporting biography, and the difficulty is never the documents. It is the small talk. A legend fails when someone asks which school you went to and the answer takes half a second too long.
Dead Drops, Cutouts and Brush Contacts
A dead drop is a hiding place where one person leaves material and another collects it later, often with a chalk mark or a drawing pin as the signal. A brush contact is a handover in motion, two people passing in a crowd. A cutout is an intermediary who knows both parties but tells neither about the other.
Collins used all three in Dublin, decades before the Cold War made the vocabulary famous. His couriers were often young women and boys on bicycles, precisely because nobody searched them. It is the sort of detail ConnollyCove looks for when covering Irish heritage: the practical arrangement behind the famous story.
Four Epochs That Shaped the Art of Espionage
Secret statecraft developed in four recognisable stages, each responding to a change in how states organised themselves. Tracing them shows how much of the modern craft was already in place long before the CIA or the KGB existed.
Each period below added something the previous one lacked: theory, then institutions, then mathematics, then scale.
Sun Tzu and the Ancient Blueprint
The Art of War, attributed to Sun Tzu, sets out five classes of spies: local, inward, converted, doomed and surviving agents. The converted agent, an enemy spy turned to work against their own side, is the double agent by another name. The text treats intelligence as cheaper than war, an argument every finance ministry has made since.
Sir Francis Walsingham and the Elizabethan Network
Sir Francis Walsingham, principal secretary to Elizabeth I, ran what is generally described as England’s first organised state intelligence service. His network intercepted and decrypted correspondence connected to the Babington Plot, which led to the trial and execution of Mary, Queen of Scots in 1587. Walsingham’s contribution was institutional: he made spying a function of government rather than a private arrangement between a monarch and a courtier.
Bletchley Park and the Mathematics of the Second World War
At Bletchley Park in Buckinghamshire, codebreakers including Alan Turing worked on German Enigma traffic, producing the intelligence known as Ultra. The site changed the craft by proving that mathematics could out-perform any number of human sources, and the broader cultural consequences of that war are covered in our piece on how the Second World War reshaped art and culture.
The Cold War and the Move to Cyber
The Cold War industrialised everything above. Agencies such as the CIA, MI6 and the KGB built permanent bureaucracies, standardised tradecraft and trained officers at scale. The move to cyber collection since has changed the medium rather than the method: a phone is now the dead drop.
The Michael Collins Intelligence Network
The Michael Collins intelligence network is the most studied example of the art of espionage being used by a movement with no state, no budget and no formal service behind it. Between 1919 and 1921, it systematically dismantled British intelligence collection in Dublin.
Collins himself sits among the most written-about of Ireland’s historical figures, though his intelligence work is discussed far less often than his politics.
What made the Michael Collins intelligence network work was not secrecy equipment but placement. Collins recruited people who already sat inside the British administration: detectives, clerks, typists, postal sorters and hotel staff. None of them needed to steal anything dramatic. They simply reported what crossed their desks.
The Night at Great Brunswick Street
On 7 April 1919, Detective Sergeant Ned Broy of the Dublin Metropolitan Police let Collins into the G Division archive at Great Brunswick Street police station, now Pearse Street Garda Station. Collins spent several hours reading the files, including material on himself, and left with the names of the detectives working against the republican movement.
It is worth correcting a common error here, because the 1996 film relocated this scene to Dublin Castle and a great deal of subsequent writing has repeated the mistake. The night on the files happened at Great Brunswick Street. Dublin Castle mattered enormously to the Michael Collins intelligence network, but for different reasons, which the section below sets out.
Dublin Castle History and the Intelligence War
Dublin Castle history runs to eight centuries, but its role in the intelligence war of 1919 to 1921 is the part most relevant here. The Castle was the administrative seat of British rule in Ireland and the coordinating point for its intelligence effort, including the group of officers later known as the Cairo Gang.
Collins had sources inside that system. Accounts of the period describe a typist working within British military headquarters in Dublin who passed on details of personnel and operations. This is the aspect of Dublin Castle history that heritage tours tend to underplay, and it is the reason the building rewards a visit from anyone interested in the art of espionage rather than in state apartments. Several of the women who carried and copied that material appear in wider accounts of notable Irish women whose contributions went unrecorded for decades.
Kilmainham Gaol, Michael Collins and the Aftermath
The Kilmainham Gaol Michael Collins connection is often stated too loosely, so it is worth being precise. Collins was not executed or held there. The gaol’s place in this story is as the site where the leaders of the 1916 Rising were executed, an event that shaped the generation Collins then organised, and as the place where the 1996 film dramatised much of that history. Anyone tracing the Kilmainham Gaol Michael Collins link on the ground is following a cinematic route as much as a documentary one, and visiting Kilmainham Gaol in Dublin makes that double layer very clear.
Global Intelligence Agencies and the Spies Who Defined Them
Four services dominate most accounts of twentieth century espionage, and their institutional differences explain a great deal about their operational styles. The table below sets out the basics before the case studies that follow.
| Service | Country | Founded or reorganised | Primary remit |
|---|---|---|---|
| CIA | United States | 1947 | Foreign intelligence collection and covert action |
| MI6 (SIS) | United Kingdom | 1909 | Foreign intelligence collection |
| KGB, later FSB | Soviet Union, later Russia | KGB 1954, FSB 1995 | State security, counter-intelligence, internal security |
| MSS | China | 1983 | Civilian foreign intelligence and counter-intelligence |
Institutional character shows up in the cases these services produced, and three in particular are still taught as examples of how sources are won and lost.
Oleg Penkovsky
Penkovsky was a colonel in Soviet military intelligence who passed material to British and American handlers in the early 1960s. His reporting is widely credited with informing Western assessments during the Cuban Missile Crisis. He was arrested in 1962 and executed.
The Cambridge Five and Kim Philby
The Cambridge Five were Soviet agents recruited in Britain in the 1930s who rose into senior positions in British intelligence and government. Kim Philby reached a level inside MI6 that allowed him to compromise operations from within for years. The case is the standard illustration of why counter-intelligence exists.
George Blake and Edward Snowden
George Blake was an MI6 officer who, following capture during the Korean War, worked for Soviet intelligence and exposed Western agents in Eastern Europe. Edward Snowden, working as a contractor, released classified National Security Agency material in 2013, opening a public argument about mass surveillance that has not closed since. The two men sit at opposite ends of a difficult question: when does disclosure become betrayal, and who decides?
Spy Filming Locations and Le Carré Filming Locations
Ireland has an unusually strong claim on spy cinema, and the most significant of the le Carré filming locations is not in Germany or London but in Dublin. For readers interested in the art of espionage as a cultural product, this is where the subject becomes properly walkable.
Screen tourism has become a substantial part of Irish travel, as the ConnollyCove guide to films shot across Ireland sets out in more detail. Spy productions are a distinct strand within it.
The Spy Who Came in from the Cold in Dublin
The 1965 adaptation of John le Carré’s novel was shot largely in Ireland. Interiors were filmed at Ardmore Studios in Bray, County Wicklow, and Dublin exteriors stood in for East Berlin. Smithfield market served as the Berlin checkpoint in the opening sequence, with a section of wall constructed on the cobbles. Dublin Zoo was also used.
This makes Smithfield the most important of the le Carré filming locations anywhere, and it costs nothing to visit. The area has changed considerably since 1965, though the scale of the open cobbled space still reads on screen, and it sits within easy walking distance of the markets worth seeking out in Dublin.
Kilmainham Gaol as a Spy Filming Location
Among Irish spy filming locations, Kilmainham Gaol has the longest credit list. Its Victorian east wing and courtyard have appeared in The Mackintosh Man (1973) and The Whistle Blower (1987), both espionage pictures, alongside Michael Collins, In the Name of the Father, The Wind That Shakes the Barley and The Italian Job.
Visitors should book ahead and check current tour times with Kilmainham Gaol Museum, which is operated by the Office of Public Works and manages entry by timed tour.
Bond, le Carré and the Two Traditions
Ian Fleming’s James Bond and le Carré’s George Smiley represent the two poles of spy fiction, and ConnollyCove’s film and television coverage tends to follow the second of them towards the real locations behind the story. Fleming wrote glamour and gadgetry. Le Carré, who had worked in British intelligence, wrote bureaucracy, compromise and exhaustion. Readers who prefer the second tradition tend to find real tradecraft more interesting than the films that borrowed its vocabulary.
Northern Ireland has since become a significant production centre in its own right, a shift traced in our guide to the making of Game of Thrones, and the same studio infrastructure now attracts thriller and espionage work.
The Geography of Spycraft: Sites You Can Visit
You can follow the art of espionage on foot in Dublin, London and Buckinghamshire, and most of the Dublin route is free. This section is the practical one.
The table below groups the main sites by what you will actually see when you get there.
| Site | Location | Connection | Practical note |
|---|---|---|---|
| Pearse Street Garda Station | Dublin 2 | G Division archive Collins read in 1919 | Working Garda station, exterior viewing only, commemorative plaque |
| Dublin Castle | Dublin 2 | British administrative and intelligence centre | State apartments ticketed, courtyards free to enter |
| Kilmainham Gaol | Dublin 8 | 1916 executions, major filming location | Timed tours, book well ahead |
| Smithfield | Dublin 7 | Berlin checkpoint in the 1965 le Carré film | Open public square, free |
| Bletchley Park | Milton Keynes | Enigma decryption, Ultra intelligence | Day ticket, allow a full day |
Much of the route passes through the streets where the 1916 Rising and the later intelligence war played out, including O’Connell Street and the quays either side of it.
A sensible Dublin route runs Pearse Street to Dublin Castle to Smithfield in a single morning, with Kilmainham Gaol booked for the afternoon. Anyone building this into a longer trip will find the logistics covered in our guide to travelling to Ireland from London.
Reading the City Rather Than the Plaques
The useful trick in Dublin is to look at distances. Collins’s safe houses, meeting points and offices sat within a short walk of the buildings he was working against. That proximity is the whole point of urban intelligence work and it does not come across in any book. Ciaran Connolly founded ConnollyCove to document exactly this kind of gap between the written account and the place itself.
For visitors continuing north, Belfast offers a parallel and more recent history of surveillance and division, which our coverage of dark tourism sites in Belfast approaches with the care the subject needs.
The city’s own story is longer than the twentieth century alone, and ConnollyCove’s account of how Belfast grew into a city gives the background that makes the later divisions legible.
Espionage, the Law and the Digital Frontier
International law does not prohibit espionage outright, while domestic law in almost every country punishes it severely. That contradiction is deliberate and long-standing.
States tolerate the practice because they all do it, a contradiction ConnollyCove finds worth stating plainly rather than smoothing over. The Vienna Convention on Diplomatic Relations governs diplomatic conduct without explicitly banning intelligence gathering, which is why an exposed officer under diplomatic cover is typically expelled rather than prosecuted. An officer without that cover has no such protection.
The digital shift has changed the exposure rather than the ethics. Network intrusion, commercial data brokers and location tracking now deliver at scale what once required a recruited source, and the argument about proportionality that surrounded the Snowden disclosures has not been settled.
Frequently Asked Questions
The questions below are the ones readers most often bring to this subject, covering the craft itself, the Irish history behind it and the practicalities of visiting the sites.
What is the art of espionage?
The art of espionage is the covert collection of protected information using human sources, deception and concealed communication. It differs from general intelligence work because it is secret by design and illegal under the domestic law of the country being spied on. Its core skills are recruiting people with access, maintaining a believable cover, and moving material without the parties meeting.
What are the four types of espionage?
Intelligence collection is usually divided into four disciplines: human intelligence (HUMINT), signals intelligence (SIGINT), open source intelligence (OSINT) and cyber collection. Only HUMINT involves recruiting and running a live human source, which is why it carries the greatest personal risk.
What is the MICE framework in espionage?
MICE stands for Money, Ideology, Coercion and Ego, the four traditional motivations an intelligence officer looks for when assessing whether someone might be recruited. It is now considered a simplification, and newer training models draw on behavioural influence research to describe recruitment as a relationship built over time rather than a single point of pressure.
Was Michael Collins really let into a police station to read his own file?
Yes. On 7 April 1919, Detective Sergeant Ned Broy of the Dublin Metropolitan Police smuggled Collins into the G Division archive at Great Brunswick Street station, now Pearse Street Garda Station. Collins spent several hours reading the records. The 1996 film moved the scene to Dublin Castle, which is why the location is so often reported incorrectly.
Where was The Spy Who Came in from the Cold filmed?
The 1965 film was shot largely in Ireland. Interiors were filmed at Ardmore Studios in Bray, County Wicklow, and Dublin stood in for East Berlin, with Smithfield market used as the Berlin checkpoint in the opening sequence. Dublin Zoo also features. It remains the most significant entry in any list of le Carré filming locations.
Can you visit Kilmainham Gaol, and what was filmed there?
Yes. Kilmainham Gaol is a museum run by the Office of Public Works and operates by timed tour, so booking ahead is strongly advised. Productions filmed there include Michael Collins, In the Name of the Father, The Wind That Shakes the Barley, The Italian Job and the espionage films The Mackintosh Man and The Whistle Blower.
Is espionage legal under international law?
International law does not explicitly forbid states from conducting espionage, but the domestic law of every country treats unauthorised intelligence gathering as a serious criminal offence. An officer operating under diplomatic cover is usually expelled if exposed, while an officer without that protection faces prosecution.
What is the best time of year to visit Dublin and Bletchley Park for this history?
April to May and September to October generally offer the best balance of mild weather and lighter crowds at both. Kilmainham Gaol sells out well in advance during summer months, and the Dublin walking route between Pearse Street, Dublin Castle and Smithfield works in any season. Check current opening hours and ticket availability with each site directly before travelling.
Where to Go Next
The art of espionage makes far more sense once you have stood in the places where it happened. A morning in Dublin covering Pearse Street, Dublin Castle and Smithfield gives you the whole shape of the Michael Collins intelligence network and a genuine piece of Cold War film history in the same walk.
ConnollyCove covers Irish heritage, cultural history and the destinations behind the stories, from Celtic mythology to screen tourism across Ireland and beyond. If this trail interests you, our guide to filming locations from Vikings across Ireland follows a similar route from screen to real place, and the ConnollyCove YouTube channel documents many of these sites on the ground.